Cultural Foundations of Mathematics

The Nature of Mathematical Proof and the Transmission of the Calculus from India to Europe in the 16th c. CE

  • 5.0 (1 rating) ·
  • 14 Want to read
  • 1 Currently reading
  • 1 Have read

My Reading Lists:

Create a new list

Check-In

×Close
Add an optional check-in date. Check-in dates are used to track yearly reading goals.
Today

  • 5.0 (1 rating) ·
  • 14 Want to read
  • 1 Currently reading
  • 1 Have read

Buy this book

Last edited by ImportBot
May 3, 2020 | History

Cultural Foundations of Mathematics

The Nature of Mathematical Proof and the Transmission of the Calculus from India to Europe in the 16th c. CE

  • 5.0 (1 rating) ·
  • 14 Want to read
  • 1 Currently reading
  • 1 Have read

From the backpage (http://ckraju.net/IndianCalculus/back_page.htm)

The volumes of the Project of History of Science, Philosophy and Culture in Indian Civilization aim to discover the central aspects of India’s heritage and present them in an interrelated manner. In spite of their unitary look, these volumes recognize the difference between the areas of material civilization and those of ideational culture. The Project is not being executed by a single group of thinkers, methodologically uniform or ideologically identical in their commitments. Rather, contributions are made by different scholars of diverse ideological persuasions and methodological approaches. The Project is marked by what may be called ‘methodological pluralism’.

In spite of its primarily historical character, this project, both in its conceptualization and execution, has been shaped by scholars drawn from different disciplines. It is the first time that an endeavour of such unique and comprehensive character has been undertaken to study critically a major world civilization.

This volume examines in depth the implications of Indian history and philosophy for contemporary mathematics and science. The conclusions challenge current formal mathematics and its basis in the Western dogma that deduction is infallible (or that it is less fallible than induction).

The development of the calculus in India, over a thousand years, is exhaustively documented in the volume, along with novel insights, and is related to the key sources of wealth—monsoon-dependent agriculture and navigation required for overseas trade—and the corresponding requirement of timekeeping. Rejecting the usual double standard of evidence used to construct Eurocentric history, a single, new standard of evidence for transmissions is proposed. Using this, it is pointed out that Jesuits in Cochin, following the Toledo model of translation, had long-term opportunity to transmit Indian calculus texts to Europe. The European navigational problem of determining latitude, longitude, and loxodromes, and the 1582 Gregorian calendar-reform, provided ample motivation. The mathematics in these earlier Indian texts suddenly starts appearing in European works from the mid 16th c. onwards, providing compelling circumstantial evidence.

While the calculus in India had valid pramāna, this differed from Western notions of proof, and the Indian (algorismus) notion of number differed from the European (abacus) notion. Hence, like their earlier difficulties with the algorismus, Europeans had difficulties in understanding the calculus, which, like computer technology, enhanced the ability to calculate, albeit in a way regarded as epistemologically insecure. Present-day difficulties in learning mathematics are related, via “phylogeny is ontogeny”, to these historical difficulties in assimilating imported mathematics. An appendix takes up further contemporary implications of the new philosophy of mathematics for the extension of the calculus needed to handle the infinities arising in the study of shock waves and the renormalization problem of quantum field theory.

Publish Date
Language
English
Pages
523

Buy this book

Previews available in: English

Book Details


The Physical Object

Format
Hardcover
Pagination
xlvi,477p
Number of pages
523
Dimensions
11 x 8.5 x 2 inches
Weight
3 kilos

ID Numbers

Open Library
OL24627187M
Internet Archive
culturalfoundati0000raju
ISBN 10
8131708713

Community Reviews (0)

Feedback?
No community reviews have been submitted for this work.

Lists

This work does not appear on any lists.

History

Download catalog record: RDF / JSON
May 3, 2020 Edited by ImportBot import existing book
April 4, 2011 Edited by 59.180.158.191 Book description
April 3, 2011 Created by 59.180.140.33 Added new book.