Rose Schrock is a plain woman with a plan. Determined to find a way to support her family and pay off her late husband's debts, she sets to work to convert the basement of her Amish farmhouse into an inn. While her family, especially her ailing mother-in-law, is unhappy with Rose's big idea, her friend and neighbor, Galen King, helps with the renovation. As Rose finalizes preparations for visitors, she asks God to bless each guest who stays at the Inn at Eagle Hill. As the first guest settles in, Rose is surprised to discover that her entire family receives the blessings. And she's even more surprised when that guest decides to play matchmaker for Galen King.