BCL-2 family proteins are key regulators of the mitochondrial apoptotic pathway in health and disease. Anti-apoptotic members such as BCL-2, BCL-XL, and MCL-1 have been implicated in the initiation, progression, and chemoresistance of human cancer. Small molecules and peptides have successfully targeted the anti-apoptotic BCL-2/BCL-XL groove that binds and sequesters pro-apoptotic BH3 death helices. Such compounds induce tumor cell apoptosis and are being advanced in clinical trials as promising next-generation cancer therapeutics. Notably, selective antagonists such as ABT-737 are highly effective at inducing apoptosis in BCL-2/BCL-XL-dependent cancers but are rendered inactive by overexpression of MCL-1, a formidable chemoresistance protein that lies outside the molecule's binding spectrum. By screening a library of stabilized alpha-helices of BCL-2 domains (SAHBs), we previously discovered that the MCL-1 BH3 helix is itself a potent and exclusive MCL-1 inhibitor. Here, we deployed this chemically-constrained peptidic inhibitor of MCL-1, MCL-1 SAHB, in a competitive binding screen to identify selective small molecule inhibitors of MCL-1. Rigorous in vitro binding and functional assays were used to validate the compounds and their mechanisms of action, and most notably, MCL-1 inhibitor molecule 1 (MIM1) displayed exquisite selectivity in these assays. NMR analysis documented that MIM1 engages the canonical BH3-binding pocket of MCL-1. Importantly, MIM1 selectively triggers caspase 3/7 activation and apoptosis of a cancer cell line that is dependent on induced overexpression of MCL-1 but showed no activity in the isogenic cell line that is driven instead by overexpressed BCL-XL. Thus, a selective stapled peptide inhibitor of MCL-1 was successfully applied to identify a high fidelity small molecule inhibitor of MCL-1 that exhibits anti-cancer activity in the specific context of MCL-1 dependence.